| Band | Album | Release Date | Reviewer |
| 1208 | Turn of the Screw | 2/10/04 | Barbara |
| 7 Seconds | Take It Back, Take It On, Take It Over! | 1/25/05 | Barbara |
| 7th Standard | Fire From the Sky | 5/20/03 | Vinny |
| A18 | Dear Furious | 6/8/04 | Barbara |
| A18 | Forever After Nothing | 2/25/03 | Vinny |
| Academy, The | S/T | N/A | Barbara |
| Acceptance | Black Lines to Battlefields | 5/20/03 | Sev |
| Ace Troubleshooter | The Madness of the Crowds | 6/18/02 | Matt |
| Action Action | An Army of Shapes Between Wars | 1/24/06 | Barbara |
| Action Action | Don’t Cut Your Fabric to This Year’s Fashion | 9/14/04 | Barbara |
| Adair | The Destruction of Everything is the Beginning of Something New | 2/21/06 | Barbara |
| Advantage, The | S/T | 4/6/04 | Barbara |
| AFI | Sing the Sorrow | 3/11/03 | Matt |
| Against Me! | As the Eternal Cowboy | 11/4/03 | Sev |
| Against Me! | Searching for a Former Clarity | 9/6/05 | Sev |
| Against Me! | We’re Never Going Home (DVD) | 11/2/04 | Sev |
| Agnostic Front | Another Voice | 1/25/05 | Sev |
| A.K.A.s (Are Everywhere), The | White Doves and Smoking Guns | 9/9/03 | Vinny |
| Alexisonfire | S/T | 9/9/03 | Barbara |
| All-American Rejects, The | S/T | 10/15/02 | Sev |
| Amber Pacific | Fading Days | 5/25/04 | Sev |
| Amber Pacific | The Possibility & the Promise | 5/24/05 | Sev |